Saturday, June 9, 2012

democracy Takes Another Hit

Heaven help us from the specter of the grown man balling his eyes out on CNN moaning about the “end of democracy as we know it”. His blabbering was replayed needlessly in news show recapping the Wisconsin recall election in which the Evil Empire of entrenched capital racked up another electoral victory.  This guy is by no means alone. He is the contemporary of the middle aged Occupy protestor who ends every sentence with “Maaan…”, her hennaed hair no doubt reeking of incense.  Though I sympathize with the cause the images of these people make me want to wretch.  Though I recognize this makes me a complete misanthrope d***head, I often just want to yell shut up when I see the images flicker on the TV screen.


Lauryn Hill was in the new this week stating the reason that she did not pay any taxes in 2005, 2006, or 2007 was because she was trying to “build a community of people, like-minded in their desire for freedom and the right to pursue their goals and lives without being manipulated and controlled by a media protected military industrial complex with a completely different agenda.”  While we can be sure that there is in fact a military industrial complex, does the media really protect them? I think it’s more that the media and the public get so easily distracted. Let’s not forget Lindsey Lohan got in a car accident this week, and friggin’ Kim Kardashian’s walked somewhere in New York, so that had to covered. Meanwhile, Ms. Hill earned $1.5 million in this period when she was on the run from the man. She tried to explain all this to the IRS, apparently thinking they were not part of this vast complex that wanted to crush her soul, but they chose to prosecute anyway. Strange…
That I am aware of all of these stories just shows what a media whore I am.


But I digress. I wanted to talk about Wisconsin.
Much has been made of the expense of the recall. Through the end of May about $66 was accounted for, but the non-Partisan  campaign finance watchdog group Wisconsin Democracy Campaign estimates that the final total could be close to $80 million, which would come out to about $32 for every vote. But the sources and amounts of some of the campaign cash are where the real ugliness occurred. CNN reported the following:


·         Wisconsin roofing magnate, billionaire Diane Hendricks, gave Walker more than $500,000


·         Texan home builder Bob Perry, who bankrolled the infamous 2004 "Swift Boat" attacks against John Kerry, contributed $500,000 to Walker


·         Las Vegas casino magnate Sheldon Adelson gave $250,000


·         Michigan Amway Billionaire Dick DeVos donated $250,000.


Four people, all of whom are spilling their corrupt cash across the political landscape spent $1.5 million to keep Scott Walker Governor or Wisconsin.
 The NY Times reports that the Republican Governor’s Association poured $8.7 Million into the campaign, and that Americans for Prosperity, the financial arm of the Koch Brother’s criminal business enterprise, spent an additional $3 million. At the height of the Iraq war, I marched with tens of thousands of others during the Republican National Convention in New York. People were angry. I remember the Fox News truck was assaulted with outstretched middle fingers. People chanted “This is what Democracy Looks like!!”  But in 2012, Fox News contributed $1.0 Million to the Republican Governor’s Association. Sadly, this is what Democracy looks like today. A corrupt system awash with so much money, some of it from News outlets which are ostensibly there to report on the campaigns, that voices of dissent can barely be heard.


In Wisconsin—the home of Bob Lafollette, the founder of the Progressive Party in America--  Walker  outraised his opponent by 7 to 1 in direct contributions, but when outside money is included it’s closer to 3 to 1.  Of Walker’s total, 70% came from outside Wisconsin. So what? When such obscene amounts of money are raised and spent in such a small and in terms of media costs inexpensive state does any of it really matter?  Let’s be honest Wisconsin is not the capital of corruption; it is really just a satellite office.
Union membership which was about 30% of all American workers at its peak is now less than 6%. In 1982 when I helped organize a feeble little Walk-A-Thon to raise money for an antinuclear/ antiwar group, we managed to raise about $10,000 after three month’s work. At the time UAW local 65 was an active ally in the movement to defund the military, arrest Reagan’s headlong rush to place Nuclear missiles in Europe, and accelerate  the process of investing in the infrastructure of the US economy.  I often saw UAW 65 people around in those days. Everyone knows that these unions, though not always bastions of progressive politics, are now just faint shadows of their former selves.


Though still politically active private union membership has shrunken so dramatically that conservatives have set their sights on public employee unions. That conservatives continue to rally against a political force, long since vilified virtually out of practical relevance,  which maybe harnesses a tenth of it former power, shows how completely the game has  changed and how fervently they want to wipe out any opposition to the unfettered application and power of capital.  Though conservatives suffered a setback in Ohio, where voters rebuked Republicans governor’s Kasich’s efforts to outlaw collective bargaining, they scored an obliterating neutron bomb victory in Wisconsin.  The buildings stand. Everything else is gone.
Scott Walker in Wisconsin initially wanted big public sector union givebacks. He got them, and then showing the real teeth of the conservative coalition he pushed for legislation to outlaw collective bargaining on a basketful of issues in the future. This virtually guarantees that teachers, fire fighters, and DMV employees will never again have recourse to claw any of these concessions back in the future.  The Unions which invested million in the battle were massively outspent. Hello Citizens United, goodbye, democracy, “Maaan…”


Americans it seems have come to the conclusion that consolidated wealth is good and workers are just annoying impediments in the furtherance of that goal. Nothing it seems angers Americans anymore unless of course their cable goes out. Well, let me restate, there is most certainly anger, but mobilization is lacking and the power structure is not afraid. The threat of non-violent direct action is too diffuse and too little employed. Occupy protestors raised all sorts of alarm bells last summer and fall, but then went silent when cold weather and revised and more subtle police tactics maneuvered them into near silence.  Capital may have been annoyed, but they were never worried. In general it seems pretty clear that the Tea Party, well-funded by the same entities that paid for Scott Walker’s campaign have more staying power. Money always talks. Always.
It’s hard to believe that just a short time back in our history things looked so completely different. Calls for change on civil rights could not be silenced even after Medgar Evers was killed in 1963. A few months later four little girls were killed in the bombings at the 16th Street church in Birmingham.  Still year after year the marvelous new militancy that Dr. King spoke of continued to grow.


In 1967, Abbie Hoffman attempted to levitate the Pentagon, and the following year the Chicago Police rioted at the Democratic Convention beating and gassing ant-war protestors.  In 1970 four kids were shot in Kent State. Anti-war protests continued.  Ten days later, two more student protestors were killed and a dozen more were wounded at Jackson State.  Still despite all that, the anti-war movement driven by anxious self interest in opposition to the draft, and the horrific images of the war projected on TV screens every night (images no longer allowed) eventually prevailed.
In August 1965 the Watts riots nearly destroyed inner city Los Angeles. There was at the time a feeling that no matter the ugliness or violence change was going to come, one way or another, by any means necessary as Malcolm X famously said. 


In July 1968 riots destroyed large sections of Detroit and Newark accelerating the white flight. This was both the nadir and the zenith of the movement for progressive social change.  Middle class white American was genuinely frightened into action. However given a few years progressive social change came to be seen, and was masterfully projected by cynical politicians, as a handout for minorities and the mood in the country first darkened and then turned ugly.  Capital found a reason and a way to strengthen their hand.
This is not to suggest that positive social change has not taken place in the interim. Women’s rights, gay rights, The Americans with Disability Act, and the environmental movement all coalesced and moved forward after 1970 when it seemed that country had just had it with protests and militancy. Enlightened self-interest and more modest goals and agendas generated change. Enough of a window opened so that many of the wounds of racism, sexism, and homophobia are no longer festering to the same degree. Though, success cannot be claimed, progress cannot be denied.  I firmly believe that in a generation or two, my children’s children, or maybe their children’s children will wonder what all the race, gender, and sexual orientation fuss was about. That will be all to the good.


But while all this good stuff was taking place starting with Reagan in 1980 capital reasserted itself. It almost seems like capital was willing to concede some battles in order to protect their larger concerns.   The most profound and important changes often come when the elite power structure comes to fear in one way or another. Today there is so little fear that lies are promulgated by the day. The true elites, those with money, call those that oppose them class warriors.  The image one is left with is protests in front of the bank rallying against unfair and dangerous practices, while behind the bank the fat f*** with the shiny suit loads the van full of money. Bank robbers may have to be happy with thousands, but millions and billions are looted by those wearing fancier suits and absurdly more expensive shoes. Kozlowski went to jail for looting $81 million from Tyco. $81 million. It really was hard then even to fathom the need for the stupidly expensive umbrella stands and all that. Steve Martin’s funny and prescient comments on fur sinks come to mind. Boesky and Milken ran up junk bond fortunes in the hundreds of millions before they were prosecuted, fined, and jailed. But even these guys were small time hoods compared to the billions which were bet and lost on the sub-prime loans. Most of these losses were eventually covered by American taxpayers, so The US and the world go move forward as economic entities. Alright I get that, but the rapidity with which capital now calls for deregulation even beyond the minimal amount under which they f***ed all of us really does astound. This is our new reality. Moral hazard replaced by endless whining and complaint by institutions which are so large that government can barely contain or even comprehend their power or complexity.
Between them Obama and Romney raised almost $140 million in May. Wall Street is again awash in cash and spending it feverishly to influence elections. It’s really astounding that the large media outlets handicap the horse race of who outraised the other when the loser still managed to top $60 million and seems to schedule an event or three a week that raises another two or three million. One might call it all funny money until you realize that many of the elements of the Dodd- Frank legislation to oversee the financial industry have yet to see actual regulations written to enforce them. To the extent that agencies have been set up by the legislation Republicans in Congress are underfunding enforcement. When I was in China, I can’t remember where I saw it, but I read that the banks understood that that to kill Dodd Frank they did not need to kill it overturn it, they just needed to slow it down. That they have done. Yet all we hear is Dodd-Frank this and Dodd-Frank that as if the legislation has not been completely stalled out by the bank lobbyists and campaign contributions. Though profits are still weak owing to the state of the economy bonuses and salaries are roaring again and back to pre-crisis levels.


While I’m not going to weep openly about the “end of democracy as we know it”, I do think that electoral politics as a means to enact positive social change is at a standstill, if not a complete dead end.  Democrats are moderate at best and seem to have no stomach for the hand to hand combat required to move a progressive agenda forward today.  As Bill Maher pointed out last night there are no crazy mother-f***ers on the left remotely comparable to the Tea Party which would tend to balance things out in Congress. I am not as sanguine as the hordes of Hollywood celebrities, all so certain that Obama is a great or even good President. That Sarah Jessica Parker spot to win a chance to meet the president made my skin crawl. This election has come to be a steel cage death match about fundraising. I’ll wade through the swamps of filth to vote for the president, but without enthusiasm.
The results in Wisconsin are ominous. The canary in the coal mine, the last gasp of any sort of truly democratic process, hit the water at 60 miles an hour. Its lifeless carcass now lies splayed across the sand of the pseudo- beach off the edge of the yellow ramp at the Lake of the Dells. Flies pick at it while carnivores lie in wait for the cover of darkness to carry it away completely and forever. Americans will soon enough forget that there was ever a good reason to have unions, or small “d” democratic elections which were not funded by a couple dozen billionaires.  The most vibrant progressive institutions in the country long under siege are now completely marginalized, and I wonder what power structure has the courage, imagination, or will to do battle with entrenched capital. We have reached a valley in the exercise of our Constitutional Government and I really don’t see any way out.  Is it the end of democracy as we know it? I don’t know, but electoral politics looks increasingly like Oz’s massive  green curtain, behind which massive amounts of money change hands never to be seen again.  It’s all a lie, Maaan… Where we go from here, I really don’t know.

No comments:

Post a Comment